Second Law of Thermodynamics

 

The second law of thermodynamics puts the first law into context and establishes entropy as a concept. We can simply define entropy as a state of disorder that can only increase or remain the same in natural processes. Processes in which entropy remains the same are reversible, but ones that result in an entropy increase are irreversible. (For more information about entropy in the HVACR trades, click HERE.)

Although the second law states that entropy can remain the same, it doesn’t happen naturally. Every process results in a net increase of entropy, no matter how small it may seem. We cannot account for some negligible factors like friction, which still add entropy to a system and make processes irreversible. However, reversible processes still exist theoretically and are included in the second law of thermodynamics. 

The second law also describes heat movement in nature. Heat only transfers from warmer objects to cooler ones until both objects reach a state of equilibrium; hot objects cannot “gain” coldness from cooler objects. When you get into a cold bathtub, you might feel very cold, but your body doesn’t absorb coldness from the bathwater. Instead, heat leaves your body and transfers to the bathwater.

When you step out of the bathtub and leave the water alone, it won’t return to its original cold temperature. Your body heat brought it closer to equilibrium, and that process is irreversible.

 

The law’s mathematical basis 

The second law of thermodynamics states that a change in entropy in the system and environment (ΔS) equals the heat transfer into a system (ΔQ) divided by temperature (T). We can represent the law with the following equation:

ΔS = ΔQ / T

The second law also allows you to determine if a process is reversible or irreversible by comparing the initial entropy of the system and environment (Si) with the final entropy of those (Sf). The first equation below is a reversible or isentropic process, and the second equation is an irreversible process.

Si = Sf           or           Si < Sf

Again, you will never see the left equation in any real process. It is impossible to convert heat to mechanical energy with 100% efficiency. We do, however, sometimes compare natural processes to theoretical ones to determine their efficiency. 

 

Where do we see the second law of thermodynamics in HVAC/R?

The entire function of our HVAC/R systems operates on the principle that higher temperature matter transfers heat to lower temperature matter, which is why heat from the air gets absorbed by the colder refrigerant in the evaporator coil. We wouldn’t use the cold refrigerant as a vehicle to move heat if the heat didn’t naturally transfer from warmer to cooler.

As we said earlier, we also use theoretical reversible processes as benchmarks for our real systems’ efficiencies. Entropy indicates inefficiency, so it stands to reason that a process without any net entropy gains is 100% efficient.

We do that with HVAC/R compressors. Compression is theoretically isentropic because the entropy changes from the added temperature and pressure cancel each other out, but negligible processes increase the entropy in real life. However, we compare actual compressor work to isentropic compressor work. We call the resulting value a compressor’s isentropic efficiency.

 

References

https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/thermo2.html

https://www.livescience.com/50941-second-law-thermodynamics.html

Related Tech Tips

5 Simple Service Valve Tips
Service valves are so basic, and we see them with such regularity that we can miss them altogether. Before I give the tips, I want to address the tech who tells the customer it was “probably the service valve” or “the caps were loose” as a plausible reason for a leak without actually making a […]
Read more
Air Flow and Ice - A Thought Experiment
Imagine a glass of ice sitting on a table. Now, imagine you place a lid on the glass so that all the water and ice are contained in the glass. If the ice and water are well mixed, the water and ice will both be at 32°F because the ice is slowly changing state from […]
Read more
Oxygen Safety Tip - No Oil and Grease
Some of the scariest practices that occur in the field surround brazing practices and tank and regulator handling. A few obvious tips are: Store tanks completely secure and upright with nothing nearby that can easily open or damage the tank valve. NEVER store tanks in a torch kit with it off only at the torch […]
Read more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

loading

To continue you need to agree to our terms.

The HVAC School site, podcast and daily tech tips
Made possible by Generous support from