How to Set a Charge by Superheat
So many techs are OBSESSED with how to set a charge rather than understanding all of the readings, specs and system conditions that go into optimum system performance.
Before ‘setting the charge” I suggest (nay… I REQUIRE) that you do a full visual inspection of the system, have an understanding of the initial factory charge and as installed line length and measure all of the “5 Pillars” on a continuous basis.
Charging or “setting the charge” is all about getting the right amount of refrigerant in the system, not about adjusting the charge to try to make up for some other system or installation issue (as is commonly the case). If there is another issue you want to fix it at the source before charging (“nip it in the bud” as Barney Fife says).
Once you check all of those things + verify airflow (when possible/practical) then it's time to “set the charge” and sometimes you do that by superheat, most specifically on fixed metering device systems in the cooling mode.
Superheat is almost always a valid reading to take, but that doesn't always make it a primary charging indicator. With a TXV or EEV metering device the superheat is controlled by the metering device itself so you can't use superheat as the method to know when you have the proper amount of refrigerant in the system.
I know what many of you are thinking already…
I Just Want the Answer of How to Set Superheat!!!
But trust me… that isn't ALL you want or need to know. You need to know WHEN to set the charge by superheat and what it means before I tell you HOW to do it.
Join me down this wormhole will you?
What does Superheat Tell Us?
Superheat is heat, measured in degrees of temperature a vapor refrigerant GAINS above the boiling or saturation temperature (dew point in a blend). In order for a fluid (in this case refrigerant) to be superheated it must be completely changed to vapor.
The compressor is only designed to compress vapor refrigerant, so the first role of measuring superheat is to be certain that we HAVE superheated vapor going into the compressor rather than refrigerant in the saturated (part liquid) state.
The amount of superheat we have is also important. A superheat that is too low risks going to zero and causing compressor damage by flooding the compressor. A superheat that is too high means that the evaporator coil is being in being underfed with refrigerant which will lead to low capacity and efficiency as well as compressor overheating on most compressors.
Both high and zero superheat readings are very bad for the compressor so we need to make sure we get it within the design range.
How to Calculate Superheat?
Forgive how basic this is but we need to be clear on how to measure superheat before we can decide what it should be.
- Connect an accurate pressure gauge to the vapor (suction) side of the system, somewhere between the evaporator and the compressor
- Convert that pressure to a saturation (boiling) temperature or the dew point temperature in the case of a blend. This conversion may be built right into digital gauges, or it may be on a separate scale on analog gauges or you may use an app based or paper PT conversion chart to get the “saturation temperature”
- Take an accurate temperature reading at the same point (when possible) making sure the tubing is clean and the temperature sensor is making good contact with the line.
- Subtract the saturation (or dew point) temperature from the actual line temperature to get your superheat (temperature gained above the boiling point) at that point
In order for this process to work at all you need –
- An accurate, calibrated pressure gauge
- An Accurate, calibrated thermometer
- Good contact between the thermometer and the line
- Proper conversion from pressure to saturation temperature
There are actually three different types of superheat measurement that all serve different purposes. They all use the method listed above but they are measured at different points.
Evaporator superheat is measured at the outlet of the evaporator. This method of measuring superheat is most useful when setting or checking TXV or EEV operation because the job of the TXV is to set the superheat at the evaporator outlet where the bulb or sensor is located. This is especially useful in refrigeration applications, especially in rack refrigeration applications where the superheat is measured at the case.
Advantage – Evaporator superheat tells us how well the evaporator is being fed which translates more accurately into evaporator, TXV and EEV performance
Disadvantage – Evaporator superheat does not tell us the state or temperature of the refrigerant before it enters the compressor. It also can't be measured perfectly without the presence of a suction pressure port at the evaporator outlet which many split A/C systems do not have.
Total or Compressor Superheat
We most often measure superheat outside at the condensing unit before the compressor. This is more useful when setting the charge via superheat because we are more carefully controlling the superheat for long compressor life and because it is the easiest point to accurately set it.
Advantage – Compressor or Total superheat tells us the state and temperature of the refrigerant entering the compressor which helps us optimize for compressor longevity.
Disadvantage – The superheat at the coil may be different (generally lower) and may not be optimized for efficiency.
Discharge superheat isn't used very often, but it is taken by comparing the temperature of the discharge line leaving the compressor to the suction saturation. This tells us the amount of heat that is gained not only in the suction line and evaporator but through the compressor. This measurement can be useful in checking compressor performance.
When do I charge with superheat?
In air conditioning, you will be charging using superheat as the primary charging indicator when the metering device is a fixed or “piston” type
No! not THAT kind of piston
A piston is just a little piece of brass with a hole through it that can “seat” or “unseat” depending on the direction of refrigerant flow. The reason it is called a piston is because it can slide back and forth (in most cases) in this seated vs. unseated fashion.
Most manufacturers will have you charge a piston system in cooling mode using a chart or calculator where you first find the TARGET SUPERHEAT. To use the chart you will usually need.
- Outdoor dry bulb temperature taken in the shade
- Indoor return dry bulb and wet bulb temperatures
You will plug these into the chart or calculator and you will get a target superheat generally somewhere between 5 and 25 degrees.
Before you begin making charge adjustments!!!
- Check your other readings
- Visually inspect the system, especially the cleanliness of coils, filters, blower wheels etc..
- Let the system run at least 20 minutes to stabilize
- Be aware of the total system factory charge and line length
- Use a scale so you know exactly how much refrigerant you are adding or recovering
Now all you do is compare your measured superheat to the target (after you do all the other things I told you at the beginning)
- If the target superheat is higher than your measured superheat your recover refrigerant
- If the target superheat is lower than your measured superheat you add (charge with) refrigerant
Add refrigerant slowly and carefully. Blended refrigerants need to be charged as a liquid (tank upside down in most cases) so you need to take your time and throttle the refrigerant in to make sure no liquid is making it to the compressor.
Pause for several minutes periodically as you charge or recover to ensure you don't overshoot and monitor all of your other system readings as you go.
There are many apps that make this easy that you can download on iPhone or Android that will help keep you from making mistakes.
- MeasureQuick (The best diagnostic app on the market)
- HVAC School App (Pretty good but I'm biased)
- Testo Smart Probes
- Fieldpiece Joblink
- Emerson Check & Charge
Here are two videos showing the whole process using Fieldpiece and Testo probes. You will want to watch the first one…. it's really good. And while you are at it can you subscribe to the Trutech and HVAC School youtube channels?
Remember…. target superheat is a MOVING target. As the indoor load changes and outdoor temps change the target will also change.
In order for you to get it right you need to have
- Enough run time
- Accurate tools
- A dry condenser coil
- Lots of patience
And even then getting to within 3° is about the best you can do.