Subcooling vs. Liquid Line Temperature

There is a common belief in the trade that the higher the subcooling, the better the system efficiency because lower liquid line temperature means less flash gas.

This statement is only partially true and can lead to some confusion among techs.

Subcooling is a temperature decrease below the condensing temperature of the refrigerant that occurs once the refrigerant is 100% liquid. Our objective is to provide subcooled liquid to the metering device at the lowest temperature possible while maintaining the minimum pressure drop required across the metering device.

We do not want to accomplish high subcooling by artificially driving up the condensing temperature unless there is no other option to provide the minimum pressure drop across the metering device.

The “subcooling is the answer” mistake occurs when a technician overcharges a system to get a higher subcooling number at the expense of higher head pressure rather than lower liquid temperature.

The condenser's job is to reject heat from the refrigerant to the condensing medium (generally air); the liquid temperature cannot drop below the temperature of whatever it is rejecting its heat to. So, as refrigerant is added to a system, the quantity of liquid contained in the condensing coil increases, resulting in a higher subcooling number but ALSO resulting in higher head pressure, condensing temperature, and compression ratio.

As more refrigerant is packed into the condenser coil, there may be some decrease in liquid line temperature. However, much of the increased subcooling will come from an increase in condensing (liquid saturation) temperature rather than actually cooler liquid.

Take a look at the system readings above. The outdoor temperature was 80°, and the liquid temperature was 82.4°, but the head pressure and subcooling were astronomically high due to a severe overcharge.

The liquid line temperature was limited to just above the outdoor temperature. As more and more refrigerant was added to the system, the head pressure (and, therefore, the condensing temperature) was going sky-high, resulting in poor system efficiency.

While it is true that a lower liquid line temperature entering the metering device does reduce the amount of “flash gas” converted directly from liquid to vapor as it leaves the metering device, this is not an efficiency gain when the subcooling is artificially increased due to overcharging or other methods of increasing head pressure.

—Bryan

 

Related Tech Tips

A Future We Can All Hope For
We can all agree that the future we all would have expected for 2020 when we rang in the new year isn't the one we got. We are all worried and looking to hedge our bets or cut our losses in one way or another, which makes sense. Given what we now know, let's look […]
Read more
The Difference Between Variable Speed and X13 Motors
First, let's cover the basics. X13 is a brand name for the Regal Beloit/Genteq brand of constant torque motors; there are other manufacturers that make them, but the term “X13” has become pretty much synonymous with the fractional horsepower HVAC constant torque motor. Also, this article is specifically discussing the common residential/light commercial motors. There are […]
Read more
Changing Liquid Filter/Drier Cores Tip
This tip comes from market refrigeration and controls technician Kevin Compass. Thanks, Kevin! A little tip when changing liquid cores: If you start pumping them down, begin bypassing discharge gas into the shell to warm it up, push out the remaining liquid, and bring the shell above the dew point so that it doesn't sweat […]
Read more

One response to “Subcooling vs. Liquid Line Temperature”

  1. I came across this the other day.
    410a system. Txv.
    Low subcooling. High superheat.

    Figured it was low, put about 3 pounds in and subcooling never went up, super heat went down.
    Temp dif was better, but not great. I was thinking I had a restriction or bad txv, but I’m still learning and didn’t really have a clue.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

loading

To continue you need to agree to our terms.

The HVAC School site, podcast and daily tech tips
Made possible by Generous support from