Infrared vs. Heated Diode Leak Detectors

Every HVAC/R tech needs an electronic leak detector nowadays, and with HFC refrigerants getting more and more commonplace, every HVAC/R tech needs a VERY sensitive electronic leak detector. We often see three types, but let's toss out the corona discharge leak detector right off the top. It just picks up too many other types of chemicals to be useful and can easily result in false positives. That leaves the heated diode (or Pentode in the case of Tif) and the infrared.

Heated Diode

The heated diode is the standard for sensitivity and the ability to pinpoint a leak. Some common heated diode leak detectors are the H10G, the Testo 316-3 shown above, and the Tif ZX.

Advantages

  • You can move to the spot of the leak and hover over that point to detect very small leaks. This allows you to pinpoint the leak.
  • There is tremendous sensitivity on many models.
  • Many techs feel they are more accurate because the motion is more intuitive. Place the probe over the leak, and the detector goes off.

Disadvantages

  • A heated diode can give false positives from some other substances.
  • The sensor is prone to fouling from moisture and oil.
  • The sensors need to be replaced fairly often (usually at about 100 hours of operation).
  • The sensor needs to be allowed to heat up before use.

Infrared 

Infrared leak detectors are increasing in popularity over recent years. An infrared leak detector draws the sample across an optical sensor that analyzes how much IR radiation the sample has absorbed. Some common types are the Fieldpiece SLR8 and the Bacharach TruPointe.

Advantages 

  • The sensors last longer than the heated diode.
  • They are less susceptible to false positives from other gasses and maintain full accuracy for a greater range of refrigerants.
  • Very good sensitivity, though not generally as sensitive as the most sensitive heated diode models.

Disadvantages

  • Infrared detectors compare samples to one another for detection. That means that the probe generally must be moved continuously to work properly. That can make pinpointing the leak more tricky.
  • It can be more difficult to get a sense of the size of the leak because they are constantly recalibrating (in my experience).

As is true in many things, you get what you pay for, so you should expect to pay $250-550 for a good-quality leak detector. If you stick with a quality brand and read up on the technology and sensitivity specs beforehand, you will generally be in good shape with either a heated diode or an infrared leak detector.

—Bryan

Related Tech Tips

Why Compression Ratio Matters
In HVAC/R, we are in the business of moving BTUs of heat, and we move BTUs via pounds of refrigerant. The more pounds we move, the more BTUs we move. In a single-stage HVAC/R compressor, the compression chamber maintains the same volume no matter the compression ratio. The thing that changes is the number of […]
Read more
Air Velocity Quick Tips
Recommended Duct Velocities (FPM) Duct Type Residential Commercial / Institutional Industrial Main Ducts 700 – 900 1000 – 1300 1200 – 1800 Branch Ducts 500 – 700 600 – 900 800 – 1000   As service technicians, we are often expected to understand a bit about design to diagnose a problem fully. Duct velocity has many […]
Read more
The 10 Commandments of the HVAC/R Technician
One trait I've seen with good technicians is that they take their jobs VERY seriously, but they learn not to take themselves too seriously. A few months ago, I had someone tell me online that I must think I'm the A/C “god” because I'm always telling everyone the “right” way to do things. This got […]
Read more

3 responses to “Infrared vs. Heated Diode Leak Detectors”

  1. Bryan,
    I have an automotive-related question which I am hoping you may have some experience or knowledge to help. I am in a buyer’s analysis-paralysis between buying a Fieldpiece SRL8 (heated diode) or a SRL2K7 (infrared) leak detector. Which is why I found your article interesting on the general pros & cons of each type.

    I am inexperienced and untrained in using these types of tools but have a 73-year-old’s love of tinkering around with cars and diagnosing problems etc with quality equipment. I am prepared to pay the extra $100 for the infrared model if it’s the better tool for detecting R134a in the messy, cluttered world of car engine bays.

    Hoping you may have some advice for me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

loading

To continue you need to agree to our terms.

The HVAC School site, podcast and daily tech tips
Made possible by Generous support from