Fan On or Fan Auto


Full disclosure, as a technician I was guilty for many years of setting the fan to “on” at the thermostat. I never really thought of any of the negative impacts that could happen.
I wanted to circulate the air and to keep air moving through the high-efficiency air filter that most of our houses had. Later I learned that in many scenarios fan “on” is not a good idea.

For this discussion, I will be talking about the cooling season in a humid climate. Many adverse impacts may occur in the heating season, depending on the region.

Things to be aware of when running the fan “on”.

Condensate on the coil after a cooling call with the fan running will evaporate back into the living space. Some thermostats combat this by having a fan off period at the end of a cooling call to let the coil drain.

If the ducts are in unconditioned spaces, outside the thermal envelope of the house, the sensible heat will be added back to the space. If the ducts are warmer than the air traveling through them there will be a transfer of heat. If there is any duct leakage latent heat (moisture) will be added as well. Latent heat gains do not only apply to return duct leaks. Supply air leakage can also contribute to this.

It is common that the HVAC system can cause the house to go under negative pressure. When this happens sensible and latent heat will be added. A common cause of the pressure imbalance is when the duct system is in an attic or crawl space, and the return duct has fewer connections than the supply ducts.

Since the supply has more connections than the return there is more of a potential to leak air. If the supply air leaks into the attic or crawl space this can cause the living space to go under negative pressure. The leaked air is replaced with either attic, crawl space, or outside air. One CFM(M3/h) in = one CFM (M3/h) out.

Ducts in conditioned spaces with panned returns can add latent and sensible heat as well. This happens when the panned joists and studs are not sealed by the HVAC contractor on all six sides. Joists and studs are part of the building network that when not air sealed during construction, by the builder, they will communicate with the air outside the building envelope. With blower door testing, and air changes per hour requirements now code in many jurisdictions houses are being built much tighter. In an older home, with panned returns, expect to be bringing in some outside air.

Even if the ducts are sealed, and 100% in the conditioned space it still costs money to run the fan. Running a PSC motor 24/7 can be costly. (ECM motors on a properly-sized duct system do have considerably lower operating costs when compared to PSC motors.)

The duct leakages and pressure imbalances mentioned above will also occur during a cooling call. Most of the time these issues can go unnoticed because of the ability of the HVAC system to overcome or mask them.
The goal is to get maximum customer comfort with minimum power usage and maximum system longevity. In many cases, the fan being left in the ON position detracts from these goals.

Hopefully, this Tech Tip will make you think twice about running the fan “on”. Every situation is different. I encourage you to think outside the box, if you are not already.

— Neil Comparetto

Related Tech Tips

Potential for Good and Evil (The Hard Start & Potential Relay)
I have spent most of my career being afraid of hard start kits, I heard too many horror stories of start caps exploding and sales technicians telling every customer they need one. It dawned on me recently that it may be time for me to take a more mature look at start capacitors, potential relays, […]
Read more
Weighing Refrigerant In and Out
If you don't use a scale every time you add or remove refrigerant I would suggest you begin doing so immediately if not sooner. Weighing in while charging is fairly obvious and is useful so you can keep track of what you are using and how much to charge a customer. When you have a […]
Read more
Reach-In Temperature Controls
  This article is written by Christopher Stephens of JVS Refrigeration in California with just a few additions by me (Bryan) in italics. Thanks, Chris! Reach in refrigerators are an interesting side of our industry, often looked at as frustrating and troublesome. Often working in kitchens or convenience stores the refrigerators are never located in a […]
Read more

5 responses to “Fan On or Fan Auto”

  1. This is where Home Performance testing comes in. How leaky is the house? How many ducts are connected to outdoors? Are there any real stinkers that are super connected to outdoors? There is a lot of opportunity to work together. My HVAC guy likes me, I show up with high end jobs already sold for him.

    BTW measured monthly cost for running ECM motors is $3-10/mo from our projects. Sometimes even lower if you are using a modulating piece of equipment that runs a lot.

    I agree, though, as a blanket statement it’s dangerous. Cheers to you for saying so.

  2. I work in a hotel with an indoor heated pool. They have 2 cooling systems only 1 is running. There’s constant moisture off the ductwork in the high ceilings. Is that an air leakage problem from the return or the discharge air duct?

  3. I’m not an advocate for keeping the fan in the on position but it does help with de-stratification of the air in multi story homes.

  4. In Florida where I run my business, running the fan “on” re-introduces unnecessary moisture back into the living space. Even when in “Circulate” the off time doesn’t always allow for proper drain time of condensate. We always recomend “auto”

  5. If you are in an area or have an application where fan on setting is detrimental, you must also consider other control sequences that may be creating the same scenario as a fan setting of “on”.

    For your consideration:
    Many manufacturers of whole house dehumidifiers installation practices include utilizing the AC duct system to also distribute the air for the dehumidifier and a fan control interlock that runs the AC system fan when humidity is high… let that sink in…

    So, if your house is running high humidity, then we basically set the fan to on? hmmmm

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

loading

To continue you need to agree to our terms.

en English
X