Fan Blade Shroud Depth

When a system has abnormally high head pressure (high condensing temperature over ambient) and compression ratio, one of the easiest things to look for is a dirty condenser coil. More often than not, that will be the cause.

However…

There is another category of issues that can cause high condensing temperature (high head pressure), but these result from improper practices rather than dirt and grime.

When a tech comes across a failed condensing fan motor or a damaged blade, they will often go to their van and see what they have as a “universal” replacement part. I don't have an issue with using aftermarket repair parts in some cases, but you need to make sure that the part you are using will operate properly without sacrificing capacity, efficiency, and longevity.

Often, when using aftermarket parts, a tech may be sacrificing one or more of these things. That can lead to issues.

When replacing a fan blade, you need to ensure:

  1. The pitch is a match
  2. The number of blades is a match
  3. The diameter is a match

If you change the pitch, you will also need to change the number of blades and vice versa to end up with the same CFM airflow output, which can be very tough to determine in the field.

The diameter really cannot change, or you won't have the proper gap between the blade edge and the shroud (usually 1/2-1″), which can greatly impact air movement.

When replacing a motor, you need to ensure:

  1. The RPM (number of poles)  matches
  2. Voltage and phasing matches
  3. The HP is the same or greater
  4. The physical size will allow proper installation

In some cases, the technical specs may work, but the motor body may be deeper. When this happens, you need to make sure that the fan blade can still sit high enough in the fan shroud for proper air movement. In many cases, the blade and shroud are designed to match the middle/center of the blade with the bottom of the fan shroud (cowling). If these don't match, airflow can decrease.

This issue often comes into play when a factory motor fails on smaller tonnage residential units with a less than 1/4-HP motor. In these cases, when you replace the factory motor with a universal motor, the larger physical depth of the motor and sometimes the width can result in less than designed airflow. When replacing the motor, ensure that you can still place the motor blade in the same position in relation to the blade to ensure proper airflow/condensing temperature.

Sometimes, you will come across systems that run higher head pressure than they should be. In these cases, you will want to check and make sure the motor HP and RPM are correct and that the blade is properly sized and positioned in the shroud.

As always, attentiveness is the key to finding issues, even issues caused by others.

—Bryan

P.S. – We've also written an article that contains some more considerations and the steps for condenser fan motor replacement. You can read that article HERE.

Related Tech Tips

A Critical Technician Trait in Decline
Our technician, Sam, sauntered into my office this afternoon like techs often do on a slow spring afternoon before the summer hits. It's been a long day for me, lots of training prep, a bunch of little fires, and errands to stomp out, and I still didn't get my article for the day written. I […]
Read more
Troubleshooting for HVAC/R - Data Analysis
This article is part 4 of a 5-part series on troubleshooting by Senior Refrigeration and HVAC tech Jeremy Smith Ok, so we've got our data scribbled and scratched out on paper. Maybe a bit of grease, dirt, and oil, too, if you're doing things right—blood if you're doing it wrong. Now, time to take a […]
Read more
Zonal Pressure Diagnostics—The Backtalk Series (Pt. 1)
This article was submitted by Genry Garcia of Comfort Dynamics, Inc. It is the first part of his series on zonal pressure diagnostics. Thanks, Genry! Zonal pressure diagnostics have been around for a while. Here is a brief description of ZPD from the website redcalc.com:  Formerly known as the “Blasnik methods” in a nod to […]
Read more

One response to “Fan Blade Shroud Depth”

  1. Fan depth is important. Replacing a 1/5 HP fan motor with a 1/3 HP permanently is going to change the fan depth permanently.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

loading

To continue you need to agree to our terms.

The HVAC School site, podcast and daily tech tips
Made possible by Generous support from