Does setting a thermostat too low directly cause an air conditioning system set in cool mode to freeze?
The answer is, no, at least not directly.
However, low evaporator load (low return temperature or low airflow) and low outdoor ambient temperature can both lead to evaporator coil freezing. Low indoor set-point can lead to low return air temperature which is a form of low load condition that can lead to coil frost accumulation on air conditioning systems… but it is actually pretty rare.
It isn’t the act of setting the thermostat too low that causes the freezing, it is only when the return temperature drops below the acceptable limit that the freezing can occur.
There is an important distinction we need to make before you go any further. Just because low indoor temperature or outdoor temperature CAN cause freezing, that doesn’t mean that it is the actual cause.
Many units are misdiagnosed as freezing because of these two causes when the actual cause (low airflow, metering device issues, drier restriction etc..) are left undiagnosed.
When a system is found frozen, it must be fully defrosted and tested for other issues before a conclusion is made that low set-point or low outdoor ambient were the root causes.
Most air conditioning systems are set up for around 400 CFM per ton of Cooling.
This will generally result in a 32° to 38° DTD (design temperature difference) on the evaporator coil with 35° being the established standard. This means that the evaporator coil will be 38° to 32° colder than the return air that passes over it and ice will begin to form at 32°.
Based on this, return temperatures of below 70° begin to enter a zone where freezing becomes possible (on systems set up for 350 CFM per ton for example). At a return temperature of 64° frost formation on the evaporator coil becomes likely.
Again, this is due to the return air temperature not just the thermostat setting.
Just because the thermostat is set to 67° doesn’t mean the return temperature will achieve 67°. In the case of a supply to return bypass damper as is common in some residential zoning systems, you may see a low return air temperature even when the thermostat is set normally.
Systems that have long run times and high humidity return air are the most likely to freeze the coil due to low return temperature cause by low thermostat set point. For example in Florida, I have seen vacation homes on a rainy Spring day where a vacationer sets the thermostat to 50° in cool and leaves for the day… that makes for a nice frozen coil when they return because the combination of low sensible load (outdoor temp), lots of moisture to freeze and an all day continuous run time.
A typical residential system with no special low ambient controls or freeze protection shouldn’t be set below 70° indoors or run for a significant amount of time when it’s below 65° outdoor.
This isn’t to say that they WILL freeze if you set it colder or run when it’s colder than that, but given enough run time it is possible.
It isn’t a system “running too hard” that causes it. It isn’t the set-point itself, it is the heat load on the evaporator coil that can cause the suction saturation to drop below 32°.
Once again, as a technician, never blame set-point until you have exhausted all other possibilities.